AGRI-BRIEFS
  AGRONOMIC NEWS ITEMS
From Agronomists of the
Potash & Phosphate Institute
655 Engineering Drive, Suite 110
Norcross, Georgia 30092-2837
Phone (770) 447-0335

Spring 1998, No. 8

BROADCAST VS. BAND: HOW DO THEY COMPARE?

How will you apply fertilizer this spring? Will you broadcast your fertilizer or will you band it? Many believe that band applications are always more efficient than broadcast applications. However, a closer look at fertilizer placement shows that the results can be varied. Before you decide, here are a few situations to consider.

Case 1: Broadcast applications produce the same yields as banded applications. This is more likely to happen when fertility levels are fairly uniform and high throughout the rooting zone. Uniform fertility levels in the upper 6 to 8 inches are achieved only when applied fertilizer is mixed well with the soil. In this case, there is a good chance that the fertilizer will be placed in moist soil. In drier parts of the season, as the roots explore deeper portions of the soil profile in search of water, roots will still be able to come in contact with applied fertilizer. The temperature of the growing season is also important. Warm season crops, such as sunflowers, soybeans, and sorghum are more likely to respond equally well to broadcast and banded fertilizer applications.

Case 2: Band applications produce higher yields than broadcast applications at lower application rates, but produce the same yields at higher rates. This is the case that most agronomists expect and is the basis of recommendations that reduce application rates for banding. This relationship is most likely when soils are cool and wet, fertility levels are low, and soils fix a large quantity of applied fertilizer. Fixation is defined here as transforming applied fertilizer from plant-available compounds to compounds not readily plant-available. For example, soils that fix phosphorus typically have higher levels of aluminum and iron oxides or higher levels of free calcium carbonate. In soils that fix applied fertilizer, banding reduces the amount of soil that the fertilizer contacts. This results in more of the fertilizer remaining plant-available in the season of application.

Case 3: Band applications produce higher yields than broadcast applications regardless of rate. This may be observed in cool, wet soils when banded fertilizer stimulates early growth and the early growth is critical for attaining maximum yields (starter effect). A second set of circumstances where this relationship may be observed is with relatively low soil test levels, minimal incorporation of broadcast fertilizer, and dry soil surface conditions. Low soil test levels may not always be necessary to see this response. For instance, studies have shown yield increases from banded potassium in ridge-till and no-till systems, even at very high soil test levels of potassium. Optimum band rates may be higher than optimum broadcast rates.

Case 4: Broadcast applications are more efficient than band applications. This is likely to occur on soils that do not fix much of the applied fertilizer, have heavy residue cover, and are warm and moist. Examples of this are no-till systems in humid regions and under irrigation. In these cases, roots proliferate near the soil surface, where broadcast fertilizer is most concentrated. Fertilizer banded deeper below the surface may not contact the roots as much as the broadcast fertilizer.

So which is better, band or broadcast? This discussion has shown that band and broadcast applications will help reach maximum yields under different situations. Knowing which situation you have will help you decide how best to apply your fertilizer this spring.


-TSM-

For more information, contact Dr. T. Scott Murrell, Northcentral Director, PPI, 14030 Norway Street, NW, Andover, MN 55337. Phone: (612) 755-3444.
Copyright 1996-2017 by Potash & Phosphate Institute. All rights reserved.